Toll Free
(614) 799-5000
(800) TOY-BARN
5100 Post Road, Dublin, Ohio 43017



Leonard F.
Lodi, NJ.
April 2014

You have a really great operation, and i will look to you for my next Corvette. I have told all my "car guy" friends about your excellent operation.
Thank you


Shawn G.
Fairland, In
March 2014

Justin is awesome! So is everyone else -- I have received follow-up calls and all issues with car are being taken care of.


Brian N.
Gahanna, Oh
March 2014

I LOVE THE TOY BARN. Greg deserves a new watch !


Scott & Rosemary L.
Gahanna, Oh
April 2014

I enjoyed doing business with. Great selection, fair pricing and wonderful service.


Alexander O.
Cambridge, MA
February 2014

Great service, great communication. Can't wait to receive the bike!
Thanks guys


Gregory S.
Westerville, Oh 
April 2014

Without a doubt, the best experience I've ever had in purchasing a vehicle. Thanks!


Michael M.
Powell, oh
April 2014

This is my third car in less than 4 years. I have always been treated well and taken care of in a professional manner. Matt has always been great!
Adrian makes everything so easy, he is 100% customer focused.


Bejamin P.
Dublin, Oh
March 2014

2nd car bought at Toy Barn, very professional and easy, no silly sales games. Excellent!

Charles H.
Logan, oh
2011 Harley Davidson
March 2014

Everyone was very helpful and great

Nov. 8, 2013
Mr. M Cowgill Jr.
Canal Winchester, Oh

Dominic (Turnoc) was a pleasure to work with throughout the whole process, Great to work with!

Nov. 07, 2013
Mr. A Johnson
Martinsville, IN

Best car buying experience I've ever had. My next car will come from the Toy Barn.

September 30, 2013

Mr. R. Powell
Columbus, Oh 43228

Always a pleasure dealing with everybody @ the Toy Barn. Purchased 3 vehicles so far, I will be back!

October 3, 2013

Mary Fox Bolich
Hillsboro, Oh

The most fun my husband and I ever had visiting a car showroom. We may have to visit just to see the other toys!
Thank you.



I would like to thank the Toy Barn for my new Smart Car. Thanks again, I will be back for my next purchase. 
Keep your eyes out for a nice Toyota Prius for me!

Thanks again Justin and Erick,
Your customer always,
Matt S.


June 28, 2013

Justin Hinderer
Toy Barn
5100 Post Rd.
Dublin, Oh 43017

Dear Justin,

Thank you for your support of the Arthritis Foundations Classic Auto Show & Cruise-in.
On July 12 & 13, 2013, we'll celebrate 31 years of this spectacular event, and we look
forward to another weekend of great music, wonderful automobiles and the mission of
the Arthritis Foundation.

Without your generosity and passion for this event, the Classic Auto Show & Cruise-in
would not experience the success we enjoy. your support helps bring nearly $200,000
to the Arthritis Foundation annually. The Arthritis Foundation is committed to raising
awareness and reducing the unacceptable impact of arthritis, which strikes one in every
five adults and 300,000 children, and is the nation's leading cause of disability, To
conquer this painful, debilitating disease, we support education, research, advocacy and
other vital programs and services.

Please feel free to be in touch with any questions about the show or enclosed


Stephanie Perry
Community Development Manager
Arthritis Foundation


July 1, 2013

Mr. Justin Hinderer
Toy Barn Cars
5100 post rd.
Dublin, Ohio 43017

Dear Justin:

Thank you and your company, Toy Barn, for your generous donation of
$1000.00 to Beat the Heat, Inc. Your generosity will allow the 2013 Beat the
Heat World Finals to be our finest motorsports gathering since our organization
was founded in 1992

Beat the Heat, Inc. is a national 501.C3 non profit comprised of police officers
and firefighters who conduct educational programs using replica emergency
vehicle drag cars to gain the interest of the public. We have chapters throughout
the world.

As a presenting sponsor, I want to send you your 10 t-shirts right away. Let me
know what sizes you need (mens) and please send a digital copy of your Toy
Barn logo. You can send those to me at .

Again, thanks so much for supporting Beat the Heat.


Anthony W. Shepard
Chief of Police


1950 Arlingate Lane
Columbus, OH 43228

May 1, 2013

Justin Hinderer
Toy Barn
5100 Post Road
Dublin, OH 43017

Dear Justin:

Thank you for your support and generous gift for the American Lung Association's Buckeye
Celebrity Golf Tournament that was held on Monday April 22nd at the Ohio State Golf Club.

We are so thrilled that at our inaugural event, we were able to giveaway such an amazing car!
Your generosity and support will go down in history, within our tournaments, for years to come!

Your generosity will greatly help the American Lung Association of Ohio continue our work
toward our mission to prevent lung disease and promote lung health through education,
community service, research and advocacy.

The inaugural event of the Celebrity Golf Tournament was a tremendous success ! Over
$40,000 was raised form sponsorships and tournament day activities.

I look forward to seeing you at the 2014 tournament


Brittany Sinzinger
Development Coordinator
                                                                                 Mr. Dennis.
                                                                                 Granville, Oh
                                                                                 April 02, 2013
             Chris was great - from responding to my original email concerning the BMW, right through to making sure
             I got what I needed for the car, Complete professional.
                                                                                      Mr. Timothy 
                                                                                      Galena, Oh
                                                                                       April, 2013
              I called "last minute", Jonathan (service manager) said bring it on!
                                                                                        Mr. Henry  
                                                                                        Dublin, Oh
                                                                                        March 16, 2013
            I have been purchasing autos dating back to 1978. I've never had a salesman as pleasant as Dominic Turnock.
            Thanks Dominic !

                                                                                           Mr. Richard  
                                                                                           Columbus, Oh
                                                                                           February 3, 2013
           This was the second vehicle that I have purchased form the Toy Barn, and I plan on purchasing more!
           The sales and service departments are a real breath of fresh air in the auto dealer industry. From the first
           class selection of vehicles, to the way you treat your customers, you guys have found the winning
           combination. Keep doing exactly what you are doing.
                                                                                              Burke, VA 22105
                                                                                              January 13, 2013
             Dear Toy Barn,
             I just wanted to write some comments for your survey.I have had a great experience with Erick. This is now my second vehicle that I
             have purchased form Toy Barn and I am glad that erick was around to help me with my purchases. I live out of state, so its harder to
             purchase a car when you don't see it in front of you. Erick walked me through the car and descibed it in such detail that I was convinced.
             I have gained a trust with Erick and Toy Barn and know the quality that is there when I purchase a car. We are both car enthusiasts and
             it is great to know that he was able to put me in the drivers seat.
             I want you to know that you have not only sold me a car but an experience. I am grateful for your staff; both Erick and Adrian were
             great to help me. The day i make big bucks I'll be back to buy a couple Ferraris. Thanks for everything.

                                                                                                    Lowell and Patricia  
                                                                                                    Dublin, Oh
                                                                                                    January 26, 2013
                                                           5th car we have purchased for the Toy Barn. It just keeps getting better.
                                                      Justin, Greg and Jim (service) are always great to work with on all aspects of our deals.
                                                                                                     Galena, Oh
                                                                                                     June 25, 2012
                                                                 Always an OUTSTANDING experience at the Toy Barn
                                                                 2009 Mercedes-Benz SL550 delivered 06/20/12 by Greg Mcdevitt

                                                                                                    Chicago, IL 60645
                                                                                                      June 29,2012
            I never thought that I would buy a used car online. I envisioned that I would've had to drive six
            hours to the dealership so I could personally check out the car. After speaking with Justin he put
            my mind at ease by going to the car and going over each and every item I questioned and
            gave me an honest assessment of the vehicle. The other staff members at the Toy Barn were
            also a cut above the rest. Adrian processed the paperwork in a very timely fashion and was
            always available when I called. Darren spent some time reviewing the car when he delivered it
            to my doorstep. They all made the buying experience a lot easier than I could've ever dreamed.
            I would purchase another vehicle from him in a heartbeat.
            Richard XXXXX                              


From: Chris Griffith
Sent: Wednesday, July 20, 2011 2:19PM
To : Jonathan Hinderer
Subject : BMW 135i
Hey Jonathan,
Just wanted to again say thank you for the work you guys did on my 135 (suspension and exhaust.) I finally got my wheels on and other CF parts installed and managed to get out and take a few photos of the car. I thought I would shoot you guys a couple so you could see how it turned out.
Thanks again!
Chris Griffith


From: Jeff Beam
> > Sent: Saturday, April 30, 2011 2:24 PM
> > To: Jonathan Hinderer
> > Cc: Justin Hinderer
> > Subject: Lotus Driving Impressions
> >
> > Hi Jonathan,
> >
> > I just arrived home from the Toy Barn. In a word: WOW!!! This car has morphed into something completely different -- everything I had hoped for and more. Loads of torque from 4 grand on up. Nirvana. The exhaust is awesome too. I had to stop at the rest area on 70 and take the top off because I couldn't get enough of the sound. Thanks to you and the guys for transforming my car and for working so quickly. I couldn't be happier!
> >
> > Jeff

From: Rachel Wright
Sent: Wednesday, March 23, 2011 12:12 PM
To: Justin Hinderer
Subject: Re: X3
Hi Justin!

First off, I just want to say a big THANK YOU for my BMW. Jim arrived exactly when he said he would, and had my gorgeous car unloaded so fast! He was great!

It is such an awesome car, better than I could ever have imagined! It looks unbelievable, your detail team did such a great job making it look like a brand new car! It drives absolutely beautifully - so much fun to take out on the highway!! After months of searching, I have my perfect car! :)

I was a little hesitant to buy a used car without seeing it first, but you and your team were so great to work with! Everyone was so friendly and helpful and answered all of my questions so promptly, it made my experience so much less stressful. You and your staff were just great! I searched for months for my BMW and I talked with a lot of the "typical" pushy car salesmen, and your customer service and level of professionalism is by far the BEST - nothing typical about it - you run a fantastic operation! I will definitely recommend you to anyone I know looking to find a great car!

One thing is, I did not receive the manual booklet, do you happen to have it there or did it not come with one? I can get the info online if not. Also, I have the delivery confirmation form here that I have signed. Would you like me to fax it or mail it back to you? Let me know and I will get it right out!

Thank you again for everything, it was a pleasure to do business with you and I am so happy with my new car!

Best regards,


Toy Barn Staff:
Thank you to Justin,Mike,Greg,Adrian and all for what has been the best customer experience of my life!!!
I recently met you all and found an amazing deal at the Toy Barn, trumping every other dealer in town in every coneivable way. I work
in customer service mysely and was blown away at the level of knowledge and care employed at 5100 Post Rd. My trade-in was appreciated and
then some and your expertisepointed me in the right direction of the exact car I was looking for - Mike even spent 2+ hours on a Friday night
teaching me how to drive it!
Since my purchase, I have had all of my expectations overachieved and I absolutely love my new car! I can count on using the Toy Barn for my
next automobile purchase and you can count on referrals from me in 2011.
With much respect,
Mark Finney
From: "Yeliseyenko, Vadim I"  Date: Oct 16, 2010 11:38 AM
Subject: Please pass this one to Jonathon, this is a praise for the BMW 750 purchase

Hi Greg,


Please pass this on to Jonathan. I came in to look at the BMW 750Li that you had listed on your website. My intention was just to check it out and to see how nice it is. I was basically scoping out a potential future purchase. I have a very new, very reliable Infiniti G37x and I really did not need a new car.


However, due to the excellent experience I had this past Saturday with Erick, I really enjoyed the vehicle and the service of the sales representatives and the managers at Toy Barn. I came right back on Monday to purchase the BMW 750Li and dealt with Greg. I got a really great deal on the car and got a discount on the warranty. I do not believe in haggling, and the price, indeed, was a no-haggle price. The vehicle was competitively appraised, clean, low-mileage, and well maintained by the previous owner.


This past week, I have had numerous face-to-face interactions with the owner, Jonathan, and the two managers, Erick and Greg. Certain things were still owed to me for the vehicle, like the mats, key, etc.; and the staff at Toy Barn is keeping their promises and has a service far beyond my expectations. I give praise when I believe it is due. I have purchased Audi’s, Mercedes’s, and Infiniti’s before at the actual respective dealerships, but the service and loyalty to clients at Toy Barn surpassed them by far.


I am confident that I will continue to receive preferential treatment, and I will definitely be coming back ONLY to Toy Barn from now on for my future vehicle needs. 



Vadim Yeliseyenko









Date: Tue, 22 Jun 2010 16:02:20 -0400
Dear Jonathan:
This is to acknowledge and thank you for the very excellent services that we received from you and your team at the Toy Barn when our car unexpectedly broke down on the interstate.  The misfortunes and disadvantaged position of customers when their cars are being repaired are well known and reported.  The service provided was even more remarkable because we were out of state travelers who were mistakenly towed to the Toy Barn.  However, once there, we decided to "take a chance" because the initial reception was professional, friendly, and caring.  The mechanic was superb and refused to settle for damaged parts and, in fact, refused two engines that were not up to his standards.  We also received a loaner until our car was ready.  It is therefore our pleasure to highly recommend, without reservation, the services of the Toy Barn
Al and Ann Obayuwana

Gary Plemons 
Sent: Tuesday, September 07, 2010 10:31 AM
To: Jonathan Hinderer
Subject: Gary Plemons



It was good to meet you on Saturday and see your operation.  I appreciate your organization and efficiency with all of the paperwork so that we could start the long trip back home in the minimum amount of time.  The car performed great and we arrived in OKC at 2:30 AM on Sunday.  Your representation of the car was accurate and honest, and for that again I thank you!  Best wishes with your business venture and I trust your unique concept will be very profitable for you and your brother.


Thanks again!

 Gary Plemons

Pillar Contracting, Inc.

Sep 7th, 2010
Mr. Justin Hinderer
Dear Justin,
I wanted to thank you for a very smooth transaction, and I am very much enjoying my first Bentley. First off, the car I picked up was exactly as described on your website and on
Ebay. I had zero suprises, thank you. The car is in amazing condition-just like you said it was.
Secondly, the transaction and transfer paperwork all went very smoothly and faster than I expected. I had the car successfully registered in my name in Florida less than
2 weeks after I picked it up, very nice job by the people who process your deals. Again, everything from the work you did with the bank to get me a great rate, to the
paperwork was all done exactly as you said it would be., no suprises.
Finally, I wanted to let you know that Greg Mcdevitt came through for me every time i had a question. he was on top of everything, found me extra keys, books, and had the car
ready to go when i was ready topick it up. I found him tvery knowledgeable and a very easy guy to deal with.
Justin, I am very happy I got my Bentely at the Toy Barn. And I will make sure my Columbus friends know what a great experience I had
Again, many thanks,
Rod Dillehay
September 7th, 2010
To: Whom It May Concern
From: Matt Rolison
To whom it may concern:
The purpose of this letter is to offer my sincere recommendation of Justin Hinderer and The Toy Barn in Dublin Ohio. I have bought 3 cars from out of state dealers in the
past, but I have never had a better experience. The negotiation process was fair, the follow up was great, and the car arrived better than described. As a sales manager for
our television stations, i am familiar with the sales process and noteasily impressed, I was very impressed with Justin and the Toy Barn. Please feel free to contact me
directly to discuss my experience in detail. Please accept this as a strong recommendation.
Matt C. Rolison

July 5th, 2010


The vehicle arrived in good order this evening.  Everything is as advertised and in very good condition.  I appreciate the full tank of gas too.
You driver was very courteous and helpful.  Please pass this on the the transport service.
Gregory M. Stone